Best pizza in OH

Come Share Our Passion for Authentic NY Style Pizza

Fresh Slices on the Fly.... Fly Pies Made to Order

Fresh Slices on the Fly.... Fly Pies Made to Order
Our pies are baked fresh on hand-made, hand-stretched dough with the finest tomatoes & cheeses and the highest quality meats and produce. Grab a slice for a quick lunch or bring a stack of pies home to delight your family and friends!

Now Open at Two Convenient Locations

Now Open at Two Convenient Locations
Visit our OG slice joint on Reading Road in Evendale or hit us up the new Gatherall at Factory 52 in Norwood. Either way, we can't wait to see you!
Order Online

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Loophole Pizza

Chicken, cheese, bacon, jalapeño, caramelized onions, ranch

Trophy Cheesecake

House made classic NY style cheesecake topped with fresh whipped cream

Mexican Coke

Classic coca cola made with real cane sugar in an iconic glass bottle

Deluxe Calzone

Add up to 4 fillings from to a cheese calzone. Served with pizza sauce

3 Meatballs

Our house made meatballs made with beef, pork, veal & ricotta cheese along with a mixture of delicate, fragrant herbs and spices. Served in red sauce with freshly grated Parmesan cheese

Classic Caesar Salad

Chopped romaine, Parmesan, creamy Caesar. Large enough for a meal or as a side for two

Grandma Pizza

Pan-baked square pie. Garlic, olive oil, whole milk & fresh mozzarella, basil, topped with red sauce. Customize with toppings of your choice

Margherita Pizza

Red sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, extra virgin olive oil. Customize with toppings of your choice

Plain Pizza

Red sauce, Parmesan, whole milk mozzarella. Customize with toppings of your choice

Pepperoni Pizza

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

Their traditional pizzas are to die for but the grandma pizza has my heart. I don’t know how they get a crust that thick so airy but crispy on the bottom. It must be magic.

RJ G.

RJ G.

Super fresh New York style pizza loved the white pizza added mushrooms it was so crispy and loved the ricotta! They do perfect half and half pizzas too, fiance loved his side of bacon and cheese

Erika R.

Erika R.

I think this is the best pizza in town, and absolutely the most authentic NY style pizza ever in Cincinnati. The owner and staff are great - very friendly and helpful. I'm so happy I can get NY pizza this good. Give them a try and see why I'm raving about them!

Jim S.

Jim S.

Order Directly from Our Family Owned Business

Order Directly from Our Family Owned Business
By ordering directly from our website, you save on third party fees as well as elevated third party prices and earn free pizza via our rewards program. Delivery or carryout available.
Order Now!

Voted Cincinnati Magazine's 2023 Slice Wars Winner

Authentic NY Style Pizza Right in the Queen City

Authentic NY Style Pizza Right in the Queen City
Our pies are baked on the stone deck of 600 degree ovens creating a slightly charred, crispy crust with just the right sourdough chew. Our classic plain pie is topped with bright, fresh tomato sauce, a touch of freshly grated parmesan and creamy whole milk mozz to create an alchemical phenomenon with every bite.

Every Day. Special Days. We Got You!

Every Day. Special Days. We Got You!
Grabbing a quick lunch? Feeding a family or an office? Throwing a party? We have just what you need. Our 20" pies are real crowd pleasers, feeding 3-6 people each. Order a stack and you'll be the host of the year. Put an easy, healthy dinner on the table with a pie and a couple salads. Or stop in and throw down a slice or three. We'll have you smiling in a New York minute. And whatever you do, don't forget cheesecake!

Featuring

Catering

Healthy Options

Easy Parking

Trophy Pizza Rewards

Trophy Pizza Rewards
Stay up to date on all things Trophy and earn free food by joining our rewards program!

Frequently asked questions

Our locations