Online Ordering
Classic Pies
20" Pie
The ultimate classic, featuring crisp, chewy crust, bright, tangy sauce, and creamy whole milk mozzarella. Customize your with toppings of you choice. Serves 3-5.
$23.00
20" Margherita Pie
Pure pizza beauty. Bright tomato sauce, parmesan, fresh mozz, fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil. Customize with toppings of you choice. Serves 3-5.
$25.00
20" White Pie
A balance of simplicity and indulgence with mozzarella, creamy ricotta, caramelized onions, fresh basil, garlic and olive oil. Customize with toppings of your choice. Serves 3-5.
$26.50
20" Pepperoni Pie
Our best seller 8 days a week. The classic plain pie topped generously with delicious cup-and-char pepperoni. Serves 3-5.
$29.50
Grandma Pie
A Brooklyn and Long Island classic pan pizza. Sauce on top with fresh mozz, fresh basil, fresh garlic and plenty of love, just like Grandma would make it. Customize with toppings of your choice. Serves 4-6.
$26.50
12" Gluten Free Pie
Delicious Trophy flavors on a 12" GF, nut-free crust. Serves 1-2.
$14.50
Flat Rate 20" Pie
Add up to 4 toppings to our classic red pie for a fixed price.
$37.50
Flat Rate Grandma Pie
Add up to four toppings to our classic Grandma Pie for one fixed price.
$37.50
Flat Rate 20" Margherita Pie
Add up to four toppings to our classic margherita pie for one fixed price.
$37.50
Flat Rate 20" White Pie
Add up to 4 toppings to our classic white pie for one fixed price.
$37.50
Flat Rate 12" Gluten Free Pie
Our classic Gluten Free pie with up to four toppings for a fixed price.
$21.50
Specialty Pies
20" Loophole
Trying not to eat pizza? (Why?) Here's your loophole. A white pie with bacon, chicken, jalapeños and caramelized onions. Finished with Ranch. Serves 3-5.
$33.00
20" White Hot
An instant classic. White pie with ricotta, pepperoni, capicola and hot honey. Serves 3-5.
$34.00
20" Yes Way
Red pie with capicola, sausage, red onion and banana peppers. Serves 3-5.
$33.00OUT OF STOCK
20" Verrazano
One of our favorite pies. Fresh mozz, ricotta, fresh garlic, red onion, light anchovies and bright red sauce on top. Serves 3-5.
$31.00
20" Trophy Pie
Our favorite "Plain Pie" The ultimate classic with with fresh mozz and a touch of extra red sauce on top. Serves 3-5.
$29.00
20" Arthur Avenue
Red pie with pepperoni, sausage, and bacon. Fuggetaboudit. There's nuthin' wrong with that. Serves 3-5. Or maybe 1.
$34.00
20" Vodka Meatball Pie
White based pie with homemade meatballs and topped generously with our homemade vodka sauce and fresh basil. Serves 3-5.
$34.00
Salads
Large Caesar Salad
Our favorite salad of all-time. Romaine, croutons, homemade creamy Caesar dressing, freshly grated parmesan. Serves 1-2.
$10.50
Small Caesar Salad
Our favorite salad of all-time. Romaine, croutons, homemade creamy Caesar dressing, freshly grated parmesan. Serves 1.
$6.50
Large When In Rome Salad
A midwestern special. Mixed greens, crispy bacon, grilled chicken, tomato, onion, banana peppers, croutons, homemade Ranch. Serves 1-2.
$13.75
Large Fresh & Cool Salad
Mixed greens, tomato, onion, cucumber, croutons & choice of dressing. Ranch or red wine vinaigrette recommended. Serves 1-2.
$8.75
Small Fresh & Cool Salad
Mixed greens, tomato, onion, cucumber, croutons & choice of dressing.
$5.50
Dessert
Drinks
Mexican Coke
$3.25
Mexican Fanta
$3.25
Mexican Sprite
$3.25
Boylan's Black Cherry Soda
$3.25
Boylan's Creamy Red Birch Beer
$3.25
Boylan's Ginger Ale
$3.25
Boylan's Grape Soda
$3.25
Spring Water
$2.00
San Pellegrino Sparkling Water
$2.50
San Pellegrino Aranciata
$2.50
San Pellegrino Limonata
$2.5012oz Coke Can
$1.85
12oz Diet Coke Can
$1.8512oz Dr. Pepper Can
$1.8512oz Sprite Can
$1.8512oz Coke Zero Can
$1.85
Catering
Classic Pies
20" Pie
The ultimate classic, featuring crisp, chewy crust, bright, tangy sauce, and creamy whole milk mozzarella. Customize your with toppings of you choice. Serves 3-5.
$23.0020" Margherita Pie
Pure pizza beauty. Bright tomato sauce, parmesan, fresh mozz, fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil. Customize with toppings of you choice. Serves 3-5.
$24.0020" White Pie
A balance of simplicity and indulgence with mozzarella, creamy ricotta, caramelized onions, fresh basil, garlic and olive oil. Customize with toppings of your choice. Serves 3-5.
$26.0020" Pepperoni Pie
Our best seller 8 days a week. The classic plain pie topped generously with delicious cup-and-char pepperoni. Serves 3-5.
$29.50Grandma Pie
A Brooklyn and Long Island classic pan pizza. Sauce on top with fresh mozz, fresh basil, fresh garlic and plenty of love, just like Grandma would make it. Customize with toppings of your choice. Serves 4-6.
$26.0012" Gluten Free Pie
Delicious Trophy flavors on a 12" GF, nut-free crust. Serves 1-2.
$14.50
Specialty Pies
20" Loophole
Trying not to eat pizza? (Why?) Here's your loophole. A white pie with bacon, chicken, jalapeños and caramelized onions. Finished with Ranch. Serves 3-5.
$33.0020" White Hot
An instant classic. White pie with ricotta, pepperoni, capicola and hot honey. Serves 3-5.
$33.0020" Yes Way
Red pie with capicola, sausage, red onion and banana peppers. Serves 3-5.
$33.00OUT OF STOCK20" Verrazano
One of our favorite pies. Fresh mozz, ricotta, fresh garlic, red onion, light anchovies and bright red sauce on top. Serves 3-5.
$31.0020" Trophy Pie
Our favorite "Plain Pie" The ultimate classic with with fresh mozz and a touch of extra red sauce on top. Serves 3-5.
$29.0020" Arthur Avenue
Red pie with pepperoni, sausage, and bacon. Fuggetaboudit. There's nuthin' wrong with that. Serves 3-5. Or maybe 1.
$34.0020" Vodka Meatball Pie
White based pie with homemade meatballs and topped generously with our homemade vodka sauce and fresh basil. Serves 3-5.
$34.00
